Claire Snyder-Hall utilizes J.G.A. Pocock, Putnam’s Bowling Alone, Thomas Frank’s What’s the Matter with Kansas? to argue that commercial culture, exemplified by Real Housewives, fosters anti-republican traits: selfishness, status obsession, vulgarity, resentment, and hierarchy-glorification. These undermine the “public-spiritedness, collectivist outlook, reciprocity, and respect” needed for egalitarian republican self-government. In her use of the concept of “false consciousness,” citizens are distracted by “bread and circuses” (celebrity vulgarity blamed on “liberals”) while supporting policies that harm their material interests. Television privatizes leisure, promotes passivity, and shifts our sense of identity from the local and community to national spectacle and consumerism. In the end, these cultural changes aid elite policies and consolidation of power within the larger decline and replacement of active, virtuous citizens with passive consumers-spectators. Media accelerates this, and the decline of civic associations’ addressed in The Stages of the Collapse of American Republicanism, Civic Associations and Community creates the void that commercial culture fills with anti-social values that clash with republican virtù.
“Why has support for progressive politics seemingly collapsed? While there are clearly many reasons, this essay focuses on the role commercial culture plays in the production of anti-progressive, anti-republican values. Using the “Real Housewives” franchise as an example, I argue that trash television shows undermine the possibility of collective action and government for the common good, by encouraging selfishness, glorifying wealth and status, and exacerbating in people feelings of superiority over and resentment towards others – sentiments more appropriate for an aristocratic hierarchy or corporate oligarchy than for an egalitarian republic. The more such sentiments spread through the population, the easier it is for right-wing forces to dismantle programs that benefit the public at large.
. . . .According to J.G.A. Pocock, one of the main challenges of republican self-government is the maintenance of the republic in time – preventing the erosion of the fundamental values, upon which republican self-government is based – and I believe we are facing such a moment right now.”
Claire Snyder-Hall, “Real Housewives” and the Decline of Civic Virtue, LOGOS (2025): Vol. 24, No. 1-2.
America’s social fabric has frayed, with declining trust, associations, and shared virtue. Hyper-commercial media does amplify narcissism and division, making collective action harder. The institutional shifts toward scale with national media, bureaucracy and global capital, that we have seen since the foundations have eroded local republican habits. However, even as technology, economics, individualism (a double-edged sword), and cultural shifts all interact, not everything is “false consciousness.” I think what Claire Snyder-Hall warns us about is the fact that what we consume shapes who we become, and republics demand better citizens. When we are ready to mature as a people, we may turn around and find our civilization in ruins, continuing to solely blame the elite.
The American Minervan 
Leave a comment