God and the People: Mazzini’s Divine Ideal, the Carbonari Networks, and the Republican Struggle Against Monarchism and Theocracy

CONTENTS

1. INTRODUCTION
2. MAZZINI AND THE ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH
3. THE CARBONARI AS A DECENTRALIZED NETWORK AGAINST ABSOLUTISM
4. CARBONARI STRUGGLES AND THE CARBONARO INVOLVED
5. MAZZINI’S DIVINE IDEAL: DIO E POPOLE
6. THE REPUBLICAN NETWORKS FROM YOUNG ITALY TO GARIBALDI’S CAMPAIGNS
7. GIUSEPPE GARIBALDI AS THE SWORD OF REPUBLICANISM
8. THE ROMAN REPUBLIC OF 1849
9. THE STRUGGLR AGAINST DIVINE-RIGHT MONARCHY AND THEOCRACY
10. A “THIRD REPUBLIC” OF THE PEOPLE
11. LEGACY OF ITALIAN REPUBLICANISM IN THE RISORGIMENTO
12. THE LONG AFTERMATH
13. RECOMMENDED READINGS

INTRODUCTION

In the summer of 1815, the Congress of Vienna concluded its deliberations and imposed upon the Italian peninsula a settlement designed, above all, to extinguish the revolutionary fires that had burned across Europe for a quarter-century. The map of Italy was redrawn not by the aspirations of its peoples but by the calculations of Austrian, Russian, Prussian, and British statesmen. The Bourbon dynasty was restored to the Kingdom of the Two Sicilies. The Habsburg-Lorraine line reclaimed Tuscany; Austrian garrisons occupied Lombardy-Venetia outright; the petty duchies of Parma, Modena, and Lucca were parceled out among compliant princes; and the Pope recovered the Papal States stretching across central Italy. What Prince Metternich, the architect of the Restoration, famously dismissed as a mere “geographical expression” was in fact a patchwork of absolutist regimes sustained by foreign bayonets, censorship, secret police, and the ideological buttress of divine-right kingship allied with papal authority.

Yet the ideas unleashed by the French Revolution and the Napoleonic era — popular sovereignty, constitutional government, civic equality, and national self-determination could not be erased by diplomatic decree. Across the fragmented Italian states, secret revolutionary networks arose almost immediately. Chief among these were the Carbonari, the “charcoal-burners,” whose loosely federated cells conspired against Restoration absolutism from Naples to Turin. Their revolts of 1820, 1821, and 1831, though all ultimately crushed, demonstrated that the Congress system rested upon coercion rather than legitimacy. And from the wreckage of Carbonari failure emerged a figure who would transform Italian revolutionary thought from a conspiratorial impulse into a coherent philosophy: Giuseppe Mazzini.

The Carbonari and their successor movements, above all Mazzini’s Young Italy, mounted a challenge to the Restoration order that was philosophical and spiritual, not merely political. Their republicanism was not a pragmatic preference for one form of government over another. This was a moral and metaphysical claim. Mazzini’s motto, “Dio e Popole” (“God and People”) condensed a vision in which republican self-governance was nothing less than a divine imperative: the fulfilment of a moral law implanted in humanity by God, a law that hereditary monarchy and papal theocracy alike violated. The struggle of the Italian republicans was thus simultaneously a war against Austrian domination and Bourbon tyranny, a philosophical revolt against the doctrine of divine-right kingship, and a spiritual contestation with the Catholic Church’s claims to temporal authority.

The arc of this inquiry proceeds from the Carbonari’s decentralized liberal-patriotic networks, through Mazzini’s systematic articulation of a “divine ideal” rooted in duty, popular sovereignty, and the unity of God and humanity, to the broader republican struggle against both temporal monarchy and clerical absolutism — a struggle whose ultimate vindication came not in Mazzini’s lifetime but in the Italian Republic proclaimed in 1946.

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7